Tuesday, February 17, 2015

Downstairs, Not Upstairs, Books

 Last week I had lunch with a friend with whom I share a love of Jane Austen, Anita Brookner, mystery novels and all things Mitford. Over our coffee, as we gushed a bit about Downton Abbey... the elegant clothes, the sumptuous settings..., we commented that maybe we should have been born one, or even two, hundred years earlier. I remarked that that would do me no good at all, since my ancestors would undoubtedly be found downstairs and not up, and she laughed that hers would be in the barn milking the cows. 

I guess that's the case with most of us "colonials." Our forefathers, for the most part, didn't leave their homes (wherever they may have been) and come to the Canadian wilderness because they were having an easy, successful life, full of opportunity. 

That's certainly true for my family. On my mum's side, I'm descended from an Irish Catholic soldier from County Kerry, who landed in Saint John, New Brunswick in 1819, having been demobbed from his regiment, The Royal West India Rangers, in the aftermath of the defeat of Napoleon. I'm sure the life of an Irish Catholic foot soldier in the British Army was no picnic. Frontier life in nineteenth century Canada was probably a relief. 

So, my ancestors definitely had more in common with the servants who live below stairs in Downton Abbey, or in Jane Austen's books, than with the families upstairs, for whom they toil. Maybe that's why I found Jo Baker's novel, Longbourn, which I recently read, so compelling.



Longbourn, although frequently described as a retelling of Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice, is so much more than that. As Diane Johnson explains in her excellent review in the New York Times, it is "an affecting look at the world of Pride and Prejudice, but from another point of view-- the servants hall, where other lives are simultaneously lived  with very different concerns and dramas." Jo Baker's novel overlaps with Austen's book in places, but is not constrained by the plot of Pride and Prejudice. Starting before P&P begins and extending beyond that famous double wedding ceremony of Jane and Lizzie Bennett to the Messrs. Bingley and Darcy, Baker's novel shows us the lives of the men and women who reside "downstairs" at Longbourn. And their hopes, fear, joys, ambitions and regrets that the family upstairs know nothing about. 

Longbourn as depicted in the A&E adaptation of  Pride and Prejudice
www.janeausten.wikia.com
Baker says that the main characters in Longbourn "are ghostly presences in Pride and Prejudice." But she brings the Longbourn servants and their down-stairs world to life, as they toil  from pre-dawn to long after dusk. After all, someone has to tend the horses and pigs and chickens, chop the wood, build the fires, cook the food, and carry water, lots of water. Not to mention empty chamber pots, mend the petticoats, sew on buttons, and do the laundry, lots and lots of laundry.

"Next door, down the step into the scullery, Sarah leaned over the washboard, rubbing at a stained hem. The petticoat had been three inches deep in mud when she'd retrieved it from the girls' bedroom floor and had had a night's soaking in lye already; the soap was not shifting the mark, but it was biting into her hands, already cracked and chapped and chilblained, making them sting. If Elizabeth had the washing of her own petticoats, Sarah often thought, she'd most likely be a sight more careful with them." 

This scene certainly puts a new face on the image of Elizabeth Bennett striding confidently (and, it would seem, admirably) through the fields, heedless of the mud. Later scenes in Baker's novel continue to paint the Bennett girls as kind in their own way, but also as utterly secure in the knowledge of their own entitlement as they are ignorant of the true lives of their servants. 

www.literarydetectives.com
I know, I know. Austen's characters are women of their time and class, as was Jane Austen, herself. And we shouldn't judge them by today's standards. And the young maids Sarah and Polly, both orphans, certainly are safe and relatively warm and well fed in the Bennett household and therefore better off than many other children in their situation. Yep, I get that. But, I guess my point is that Austen's book, while a masterpiece, does create a rather skewed vision of life. And despite the challenges faced by her characters, Austen paints a picture of an idealized world. And Baker's book tips the balance a bit, and shows us the reality that Austen doesn't. 

author Jo Baker
www.telegraph.co.uk
I have a ton more that I could say about Longbourn.... but, you really should read it and see for yourself. It's not a perfect book; I found it a bit grim in the very beginning, but I'm so glad I persevered. Baker writes beautifully, and her characters soon come alive. And before too long I couldn't put it down. 

But when I did finish the book, I started thinking of other books I had read which depicted the below stairs life of those who served the upper classes. 

Like Kate Pullinger's award winning novel The Mistress of Nothing. 


The Mistress of Nothing is based on the life and travels of Lady Lucie Duff Gordon, who journeyed to Egypt in the 1860's because it was thought the climate would improve her health. The novel is told from the point of view of Lady Duff Gordon's maid, Sally Naldrett and depicts their journey to Egypt and their very unconventional life there, described by one reviewer as "going native." Sally eventually falls in love with fellow servant Omar, and is subsequently banished by her employer. Duff Gordon's unaccountably harsh treatment of Sally in the novel reinforces the idea that those who live "downstairs" can so easily have their lives destroyed by an "upstairs" whim. 

                                 
                                                                          www.uwtsd.ac.uk                                                                                                                                 www.gutenberg.org

Since I  read The Mistress of Nothing several years ago, you might get a better idea of its merits from Clare Clark's review in The Guardian; you can read her take on the book here. I do remember that while I didn't love the book, I found it fascinating. I enjoyed Pullinger's depiction of travel in the nineteenth century, the sights, sounds and smells of Egypt which must have seemed so exciting to the two women, especially Sally. And I was especially interested in the fact that Lady Duff Gordon was a historical figure who published her own account of her travels. You can read her actual letters from Egypt on-line here. I read quite a few, and while I found a couple of passing references to Sally, there are certainly numerous passages which extol the virtues of Omar. Perhaps her treatment of Sally was not so "unaccountable" after all. Or maybe I'm just mixing up fact and fiction.



While I liked Pullinger's novel, and  I applaud her attempt to bring the "downstairs" characters to life on the page, I don't fancy reading it again.

On the other hand, I probably will go back and reread Jo Baker's Longbourn. Now that I know how it ends, I won't have to rush through the story so quickly in order to find out what happens. I want to see the characters at the beginning of the book, in the light of what I now know comes later. And I want to savour Baker's beautiful descriptions of the English countryside, crisp winter evenings, and early morning mists. 


 I haven't stopped loving the  elegant costumes and sumptuous settings that depict "upstairs" life in shows like Downton Abbey. Or the romance and drama of the lives of the "upstairs" characters in books like Jane Austen's. But somehow those books, while enjoyable, did not touch me like Jo Baker's depiction of the equally dramatic lives of those who live below stairs. 

I don't feel different about Austen's characters now...okay, well, maybe a little different. But, I don't love the Bennett family any less. It's just that I don't admire them for their courage and perseverance like I do Sarah and Mrs. Hill and James Smith of Longbourn.



What do you have to say about "downstairs" books?









     



17 comments:

  1. Yes , too true , the vast majority of us would have been scrubbing away downstairs . This is actually being more recognised when visiting 'stately homes ' & historic houses in the UK now . The servants quarters & kitchens etc are being made available to us & this , for me , is actually more meaningful than the sumptuous luxury of upstairs . I enjoyed your references to ancestors who travelled to Canada . I've traced my family history & found a very old photo of a lady in serious snow who I identified as a great great Aunt Lizzie who left the impoverished dales area of a Yorkshire for the snows of Canada . I think they were shocked at the severe winter conditions there in those days , but not enough to come back ! Brave people
    Wendy in York

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's really interesting Wendy. I must tell you that in trying to trace my Burpee ancestors, I discovered that they came to Canada from New England and before that from Yorkshire in the 1730's. And the name was originally Burkby. Over time it changed from Burkby, to Burkee, to Burpee. Ever heard of any Burkby families in your part of the country?

      Delete
    2. I'm not aware of any Burkby families myself but these surnames were changed by a pen stroke in those days . Spelling didnt seem important to the officials involved & now causes great frustration to we amateur family historians . I've ordered Longbourn , so thanks for that .
      Wendy

      Delete
  2. At a recent estate sale, I purchased a book by Maureen McTeer … “Residences … Homes of Canada’s Leaders. It is a history of 24 Sussex Drive, Harrington Lake and Stornoway. It had a brief history of Joseph Currier, the tragic loss of his children and wives. Life was certainly harsh in the 1860’s no matter what your means were. It was interesting that he had a mill in your town of Manotick prior to meeting his third wife and building 24 Sussex Drive for her. Great what you can find while browsing through a pile of old “coffee table books” on a snowy day. You may get this comment twice, sorry about that. I had written it, pressed preview and poof it was gone.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. How interesting, Cate. I had no idea that was the origin of our mill in Manotick. I included shots of the mill in a recent post. And I looked up Joseph Currier after reading your comment. His link to the Manotick Mill is explained in the website. http://www.rideau-info.com/canal/tales/ghost-watsons.html
      Thanks for sharing that.

      Delete
  3. I haven't really thought about books in terms of "upstairs" and "downstairs." I do like books that turn older novels inside out, however, like Wicked, and The Wide Sargasso Sea. So I just might give this a go!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't usually either, Lisa. I was just making a pun on that Gritish TV show "Upstairs, Downstairs." I've never read Wide Sargasso Sea... I must give it a try. Thanks for stopping by.

      Delete
  4. I, too, love Downton, and I noticed how beautiful the clothing is this season. All the dresses are exquisite, and the coats are beautiful with added design element on them. Violet has lovely coats and she appears "younger" this season.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ooooh isn't it? Maggie Smith looks so beautiful in her lavender and pale blue coats! Thanks for stopping by.

      Delete
  5. Echoing Lisa's hat-tip to Jean Rhys's Wide Sargasso Sea. Currently re-reading a novel that gives an entertaining and provocative behind-the-door view of a Parisian concierge, who's not at all what the word suggests, Elegance of the Hedgehog. There's a delightfully subversive upstairs-downstairs structure to this one.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I must order that from the library...I keep seeing it and not picking it up! Delightfully subversive is right up my street.

      Delete
  6. I loved Longbourn. Have you read Lady's Maid by Margaret Forster. Book about Elizabeth Barrett's maid Wilson. EBB's life as told by her maid. Another one of those backstairs views. Have just finished Euphoria by Lily King. I found myself captivated. Of course I will never forget Bankson, sigh.
    Sally

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I read Margaret Forster's book and loved it. So glad you enjoyed Euphoria, Sally.

      Delete
  7. Dying to read Longbourn now. Thank you for the review.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hope you like it. Thanks for stopping by.

      Delete
  8. Really loved this post, Susan. Now I want to go get a couple of books, put my feet up and read all evening. Thanks for sharing with the Thursday Blog Hop!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Pam. And thanks for hosting the Blog Hop.

      Delete

All comments, ideas, commiserations, questions, complaints... are most welcome.